Smartsheet vs Shortcut (2024 Comparison)
Smartsheet empowers teams with customizable workflows and robust automation, making it a versatile choice for project management. Its comprehensive reporting features provide valuable insights for informed decision-making.
- Highly customizable workflows
- Comprehensive reporting features
- Robust automation capabilities
- Steep learning curve for new users
- Interface can feel cluttered
Free plan?
NoStarting price
$9 per month per user
Shortcut streamlines software development with its user-friendly interface and excellent collaboration tools. Designed for agile teams, it enhances workflow efficiency and supports seamless communication.
- Streamlined for software development
- User-friendly interface
- Excellent collaboration tools
- Limited reporting options
- Focuses mainly on development teams
Free plan?
YesStarting price
$8.50 per month per userWhat is Smartsheet?
Smartsheet is a dynamic work management platform that empowers teams to plan, capture, manage, automate, and report on work at scale. It offers a familiar spreadsheet-like interface, making it easy for users to adapt and collaborate effectively. With Smartsheet, you can streamline processes, improve visibility, and drive better decision-making. Whether you're managing projects, tracking tasks, or automating workflows, Smartsheet provides the flexibility and scalability needed to enhance productivity and achieve business goals.
What is Shortcut?
Shortcut is a project management tool designed for software development teams. It offers a streamlined interface that helps teams plan, track, and manage their work efficiently. With features like story mapping, iteration planning, and real-time collaboration, Shortcut enables teams to stay aligned and deliver high-quality software. It integrates seamlessly with popular development tools, making it a valuable asset for agile teams looking to enhance their workflow and improve productivity.
Pros and Cons of Smartsheet vs Shortcut
Pros & Cons of Smartsheet
- Smartsheet offers a high degree of customization, allowing you to tailor workflows to your specific needs. This flexibility is invaluable for adapting to different project requirements and enhancing productivity.
- With Smartsheet, you can generate detailed reports that provide insights into project progress and performance. These reports are customizable, making it easy to track key metrics and make informed decisions.
- Smartsheet's automation features streamline repetitive tasks, saving time and reducing errors. You can set up automated workflows that enhance efficiency and ensure consistency across projects.
- New users may find Smartsheet's interface and features overwhelming at first. It requires time and effort to fully understand and utilize its capabilities, which can be a barrier for some teams.
- Smartsheet's interface, while feature-rich, can sometimes feel cluttered, especially for users who prefer a more streamlined design. This may impact user experience and ease of navigation.
Pros & Cons of Shortcut
- Shortcut is specifically designed for software development teams, offering features like story mapping and iteration planning. This focus makes it an excellent choice for agile teams looking to enhance their workflow.
- Shortcut's interface is intuitive and easy to navigate, making it accessible for users of all experience levels. This user-friendliness ensures teams can quickly adopt the tool and start collaborating effectively.
- Shortcut provides robust collaboration features that enable teams to work together seamlessly. Real-time updates and integration with popular development tools enhance communication and coordination among team members.
- While Shortcut offers some reporting features, they are primarily focused on development-related metrics. Teams seeking comprehensive reporting capabilities may find these options limited compared to other tools.
- Shortcut is tailored for software development, which may limit its applicability for teams outside this domain. Organizations with diverse project types may need to consider additional tools to meet their needs.
Smartsheet vs Shortcut: At A Glance
Value to Price
Smartsheet offers a robust set of features that justify its pricing, making it a valuable investment for businesses looking to streamline their operations. Shortcut, on the other hand, provides excellent value for software development teams with its specialized features. If you're seeking a tool that offers great value for project management, Shortcut might be the better choice.
Ease of Use
Smartsheet's spreadsheet-like interface is intuitive for users familiar with Excel, but it may require a learning curve for others. Shortcut's user-friendly design and straightforward navigation make it easy for teams to adopt quickly. If ease of use is a priority, Shortcut is likely the more suitable option.
Functionality
Smartsheet excels in providing a wide range of functionalities for project management, including automation and reporting. Shortcut focuses on software development features like story mapping and iteration planning. If you need comprehensive project management capabilities, Smartsheet is the way to go.
Scalability
Smartsheet is designed to scale with your business, offering features that support growth and expansion. Shortcut also scales well, particularly for agile software development teams. If scalability is crucial for your organization, both tools are strong contenders, but Smartsheet may have a slight edge.
Integrations
Smartsheet integrates with a wide array of third-party applications, enhancing its versatility. Shortcut also offers seamless integrations with popular development tools. If integration capabilities are a deciding factor, both tools perform well, but Smartsheet might offer more options.
Customer Support
Smartsheet provides reliable customer support, ensuring users can resolve issues promptly. Shortcut offers support tailored to software development needs. If customer support is a key consideration, Smartsheet's comprehensive support options may be more appealing.
Security
Smartsheet prioritizes security with robust measures to protect data. Shortcut also implements strong security protocols, particularly for development environments. If security is a top concern, both tools are reliable, but Smartsheet's emphasis on security might be more reassuring.
Overall Rating
Both Smartsheet and Shortcut are highly rated tools, each excelling in different areas. Smartsheet is ideal for comprehensive project management, while Shortcut is tailored for software development teams. Your choice should depend on your specific needs and priorities.
Smartsheet vs Shortcut: A Detailed Breakdown of Key Features
Automation
Smartsheet's automation capabilities are impressive, allowing you to streamline repetitive tasks and improve efficiency. I found it particularly useful for setting up automated workflows that save time and reduce errors. Shortcut also offers automation features, but they are more focused on software development processes. If automation is a priority for your project management needs, Smartsheet is the better choice.
Collaboration
Both Smartsheet and Shortcut excel in collaboration, but in different ways. Smartsheet's collaboration features are versatile, supporting various team sizes and industries. I appreciated the ability to share sheets and collaborate in real-time. Shortcut, on the other hand, is tailored for software development teams, offering features like story mapping and iteration planning. If you're part of a development team, Shortcut's collaboration tools might be more aligned with your needs.
Reporting
Smartsheet's reporting capabilities are robust, providing detailed insights into project progress and performance. I found the customizable reports particularly helpful for tracking key metrics. Shortcut also offers reporting features, but they are more focused on development-related metrics. If comprehensive reporting is essential for your projects, Smartsheet is the better option.
Customization
Smartsheet offers a high degree of customization, allowing you to tailor sheets and workflows to your specific needs. I enjoyed the flexibility it provided in adapting to different project requirements. Shortcut also offers customization options, particularly for agile development processes. If customization is a priority, both tools are strong contenders, but Smartsheet might offer more versatility.
Task Management
Task management is a strength for both Smartsheet and Shortcut. Smartsheet provides a comprehensive task management system that supports various project types. I found it effective for tracking tasks and deadlines. Shortcut, however, is designed specifically for software development, offering features like backlog management and sprint planning. If you're managing software development projects, Shortcut's task management features are likely more suitable.
Real-time Updates
Real-time updates are crucial for keeping teams aligned, and both Smartsheet and Shortcut deliver in this area. Smartsheet's real-time updates ensure everyone is on the same page, which I found invaluable for collaboration. Shortcut also offers real-time updates, particularly for development teams working on sprints. If real-time updates are a priority, both tools perform well, but Smartsheet might have a slight edge in versatility.
Pricing Comparison of Smartsheet and Shortcut
We’ve compiled the pricing tables and highlighted the key features of both Smartsheet and Shortcut to aid in your decision-making process. Let’s explore what each platform has to offer.
Smartsheet Pricing Plans
- Gantt, grid, board, and calendar view for versatile project management.
- Rich formulas to enhance data analysis and reporting.
- Unlimited sheets, forms, and reports for comprehensive data management.
- 250 automations per month to streamline workflows.
- Timeline view for detailed project tracking.
- Team workload tracking to optimize resource allocation.
- Admin capabilities for enhanced control and management.
- Unlimited automations for efficient process management.
- SAML-based SSO for secure access management.
- WorkApps for custom application development.
- Work Insights for comprehensive data analysis.
- Unlimited attachment storage for extensive data handling.
- Dynamic View for secure request management.
- Data Shuttle for seamless data integration.
- Salesforce and Jira connectors for enhanced integration.
- Premium Support for prioritized assistance.
Shortcut Pricing Plans
- See progress on a Roadmap for better project tracking.
- Get quick insights with reports to measure performance.
- Plan sprints using Iterations for structured development.
- Integrate with GitHub, Gitlab, Bitbucket, Slack & Figma.
- Organize work by Teams or squads for better collaboration.
- Customize multiple Workflows to fit team processes.
- Manage repetitive tasks with Automations to save time.
- Access all integrations for seamless connectivity.
- Connect work to company strategy for alignment.
- Track plans with an expanded Roadmap for comprehensive view.
- Get insights with advanced Reports for in-depth analysis.
- Advanced Custom Fields for detailed categorization.
- Premier support SLAs for enhanced service.
- SSO and SCIM for secure access management.
- Custom Terms for tailored agreements.
- Dedicated Slack channel for direct support.
Our Rating Methodology
We rigorously evaluate each project management tool, focusing on key factors like functionality, ease of use, and scalability. By analyzing user feedback and testing features, we ensure our recommendations align with your needs. Each factor is weighted to provide an accurate final rating, helping you choose the best tool for your projects.
Smartsheet or Shortcut: Which One Matches Your Business Needs?
Choose Smartsheet If You Need ...
- Comprehensive project management solution
If you need a comprehensive project management solution that offers robust automation, detailed reporting, and high customization, Smartsheet is the ideal choice. Its versatility makes it suitable for various industries and project types.
- Advanced reporting capabilities
If you require advanced reporting capabilities to track project progress and performance, Smartsheet is the better option. Its customizable reports provide valuable insights that support informed decision-making and strategic planning.
Choose Shortcut If You Need ...
- Streamlined for software development
If you are part of a software development team looking for a tool tailored to your needs, Shortcut is the perfect fit. Its features like story mapping and iteration planning enhance workflow efficiency and support agile methodologies.
- User-friendly interface
If you prioritize a user-friendly interface that ensures quick adoption and ease of use, Shortcut is the better choice. Its intuitive design and straightforward navigation make it accessible for users of all experience levels.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which tool is better for software development teams?
Does Smartsheet offer more customization options?
How do the reporting features compare between the two tools?
Which tool is more user-friendly?
Are both tools suitable for large organizations?
What are the key differences in collaboration features?
Anastasia Belyh
Anastasia Belyh is a senior tech writer with over 15 years of experience in marketing, sales, and business software. Having worked in investment banking, management consulting, and founded multiple companies, her in-depth knowledge and hands-on expertise make her software reviews authoritative, trustworthy, and highly practical for business decision-makers.
