logo

SITE123 vs Big Cartel (2024 Comparison)

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Last Update

Nov 07, 2024

We earn a commission from partner links on Keevee. Commissions do not affect our editor's opinions or evaluations.

Excellent Value For Price
4.3

0

author image
SITE123

SITE123 offers a user-friendly interface and a wide range of templates, making it an excellent choice for beginners. With excellent customer support and robust features, it's a reliable platform for creating professional websites.

  • User-friendly interface for beginners.
  • Wide range of templates available.
  • Excellent customer support options.
  • Limited advanced customization options.
  • Some features require higher plans.

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$5.80 per month
Good Value For Price
3.9

0

author image
Big Cartel

Big Cartel provides a simple setup and affordable pricing, focusing on e-commerce functionality. It's an ideal platform for small businesses and artists looking to manage their online sales efficiently.

  • Simple setup for small businesses.
  • Affordable pricing for basic plans.
  • Focus on e-commerce functionality.
  • Limited template variety.
  • Fewer integrations available.

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$12 per month

What is SITE123?

SITE123 is a user-friendly website builder that allows individuals and businesses to create professional websites without any coding knowledge. It offers a variety of templates and customization options, making it easy to design a site that fits your brand. With features like SEO tools, e-commerce capabilities, and mobile responsiveness, SITE123 helps users establish a strong online presence effortlessly.

What is Big Cartel?

Big Cartel is an e-commerce platform designed for artists and small business owners to sell their products online. It provides a simple and intuitive interface, allowing users to set up their online store quickly. With features like customizable themes, inventory tracking, and integration with payment gateways, Big Cartel helps users manage their online sales efficiently and effectively.

Pros and Cons of SITE123 vs Big Cartel

author image

Pros & Cons of SITE123

User-friendly interface
  • SITE123 offers a user-friendly interface that makes it easy for beginners to create a professional website without any technical skills. The drag-and-drop functionality simplifies the design process, allowing users to focus on their content.
Wide range of templates
  • With a wide range of templates available, SITE123 allows users to find a design that fits their brand perfectly. The templates are modern and customizable, giving users the flexibility to create a unique website.
Excellent customer support
  • SITE123 provides excellent customer support, with various channels available for assistance. Users can access help through live chat, email, and a comprehensive knowledge base, ensuring they have the support they need.
Limited advanced customization
  • While SITE123 offers customization options, they might be limited for users looking for advanced design capabilities. Some features require higher plans, which might not be suitable for all users.
Some features require higher plans
  • Certain features on SITE123 are only available on higher-tier plans, which might not be accessible to all users. This could be a limitation for those on a budget.
author image

Pros & Cons of Big Cartel

Simple setup
  • Big Cartel offers a simple setup process, making it easy for small businesses to get their online store up and running quickly. The platform is designed with simplicity in mind, which is ideal for users with limited technical skills.
Affordable pricing
  • Big Cartel provides affordable pricing for its basic plans, making it accessible to small businesses and artists. The platform offers essential e-commerce features at a reasonable cost, which is a significant advantage for budget-conscious users.
Focus on e-commerce
  • Big Cartel is focused on e-commerce functionality, providing tools that help users manage their online sales efficiently. The platform is designed for artists and small business owners, offering features that cater to their specific needs.
Limited template variety
  • Big Cartel offers a limited variety of templates, which might not suit all users. The lack of options could be a drawback for those looking for a unique design.
Fewer integrations
  • Big Cartel provides fewer integrations compared to other platforms, which might limit its functionality for users who rely on multiple tools. This could be a disadvantage for businesses looking for seamless integration with other services.

SITE123 vs Big Cartel: At A Glance

Decision FactorSITE123Big Cartel
Value to Price
Excellent4.5
Good3.8
Ease of Use
Excellent4.4
Good4.0
Functionality
Good4.2
Good3.9
Scalability
Good4.1
Poor3.7
Integrations
Good4.0
Poor3.6
Customer Support
Excellent4.3
Good3.8
Security
Excellent4.4
Good3.9
Overall Rating
Excellent4.3
Good3.9

SITE123 vs Big Cartel: A Detailed Breakdown of Key Features

FeaturesSITE123Big Cartel
SEO Tools
Excellent4.5
Good3.8
E-commerce Capabilities
Excellent4.3
Good4.0
Mobile Responsiveness
Excellent4.4
Good3.9
Template Variety
Good4.2
Poor3.7
Customization Options
Excellent4.3
Good3.8
Payment Gateway Integration
Good4.2
Good4.0

SEO Tools

SITE123 offers robust SEO tools that help you optimize your website for search engines, making it easier for potential customers to find you online. The platform provides guidance on improving your site's SEO, which is a huge plus for beginners. Big Cartel, while offering basic SEO features, doesn't provide the same level of guidance or tools. If SEO is a priority for you, SITE123 is the better choice.

E-commerce Capabilities

Both SITE123 and Big Cartel offer e-commerce capabilities, but SITE123 provides a more comprehensive set of tools for managing your online store. From product listings to payment processing, SITE123 covers all the bases. Big Cartel is more focused on simplicity, which might appeal to smaller businesses. If you need a full-featured e-commerce solution, SITE123 is the superior option.

Mobile Responsiveness

SITE123 ensures that your website looks great on any device, with mobile-responsive designs that adapt to different screen sizes. This is crucial in today's mobile-first world. Big Cartel also offers mobile-responsive themes, but the customization options are more limited. If mobile responsiveness is important to you, SITE123 is the better choice.

Template Variety

SITE123 offers a wide variety of templates to choose from, allowing you to find a design that fits your brand perfectly. The templates are modern and customizable, giving you the flexibility to create a unique website. Big Cartel's template selection is more limited, which might not suit all users. If you value template variety, SITE123 is the better option.

Customization Options

SITE123 provides extensive customization options, allowing you to tailor your website to your specific needs. From colors to fonts, you have control over every aspect of your site's design. Big Cartel offers customization as well, but the options are more limited. If customization is a priority, SITE123 is the more flexible choice.

Payment Gateway Integration

Both SITE123 and Big Cartel offer integration with popular payment gateways, making it easy to process transactions on your site. However, SITE123 provides more options and flexibility in terms of payment processing. If you need a platform with robust payment gateway integration, SITE123 is the better choice.

Pricing Comparison of SITE123 and Big Cartel

We’ve compiled the pricing tables and highlighted the key features of both SITE123 and Big Cartel to aid in your decision-making process. Let’s explore what each platform has to offer.

author image

SITE123 Pricing Plans

Free
For Individuals
$0

per month

Get Startedright_arrow
Free includes:
  • 250 MB bandwidth to handle website traffic.
  • Subdomain provided for your website.
  • Basic website building tools and templates.
  • Access to SITE123's free support services.
Premium
For Small Businesses
$5.8

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Free, plus:
  • 3GB storage space for more content and media.
  • 3GB bandwidth to accommodate higher traffic.
  • Remove SITE123 floating tag for a professional look.
  • Connect your own domain for personalized branding.
author image

Big Cartel Pricing Plans

Free
For Small Businesses
$0

per month

Get Startedright_arrow
Free includes:
  • Manage your business and sell online with card and PayPal acceptance.
  • Mobile apps available for iOS and Android for easy management.
  • Import products from Etsy, Squarespace, and Shopify seamlessly.
  • Customize your store with free, SEO-optimized templates.
Platinum
For Growing Businesses
$12

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Free, plus:
  • Offer discounts and run promotions to boost sales.
  • Unlimited label printing with up to 90% off shipping.
  • Advanced template customization for a unique store look.
  • Track performance with Google Analytics integration.
Diamond
For Scaling Businesses
$24

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Platinum, plus:
  • Prioritized support and abandoned cart recovery for better service.
  • Ads with audience targeting for Google, Facebook, and more.
  • Advanced Google Analytics reporting for detailed insights.
  • Manage inventory with bulk editing and tracking features.

Our Rating Methodology

We thoroughly test each website builder, evaluating key features like ease of use, functionality, and scalability. We also analyze user reviews to ensure our recommendations fit your needs. Each of the seven evaluation factors is weighted by importance to provide an accurate final rating, helping you avoid poor-quality tools and make informed decisions.

Decision FactorScoring Weight
Value to Price
20%
20%
Ease of Use
20%
15%
Functionality
20%
25%
Scalability
20%
15%
Integrations
20%
10%
Customer Support
20%
10%
Security
20%
5%

SITE123 or Big Cartel: Which One Matches Your Business Needs?

Choose SITE123 If You Need ...

  • Easy-to-use website builder

    If you are a beginner or small business owner looking for an easy-to-use website builder, SITE123 is the perfect choice. Its intuitive interface and wide range of templates make it simple to create a professional website without any technical skills.

  • Comprehensive feature set

    If you need a platform with a comprehensive feature set, SITE123 is the better option. It offers robust SEO tools, e-commerce capabilities, and mobile responsiveness, making it a versatile choice for various website needs.

Choose Big Cartel If You Need ...

  • Simple e-commerce setup

    If you are an artist or small business owner looking for a simple e-commerce setup, Big Cartel is the ideal choice. Its focus on e-commerce functionality and affordable pricing make it a great option for managing online sales.

  • Budget-friendly solution

    If you are looking for a budget-friendly solution, Big Cartel offers affordable pricing for its basic plans. It's a cost-effective option for small businesses and artists who need essential e-commerce features without breaking the bank.

Frequently Asked Questions

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Martin Lunendonk is a senior tech writer specializing in website builders, web hosting, and ecommerce platforms. With a background in finance, accounting, and philosophy, he has founded multiple tech startups and worked in medium to large tech companies and investment banking, bringing deep expertise and reliable insights to his software reviews.