logo

SamCart vs Big Cartel (2024 Comparison)

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Last Update

Nov 22, 2024

We earn a commission from partner links on Keevee. Commissions do not affect our editor's opinions or evaluations.

Excellent Value For Price
4.3

0

author image
SamCart

SamCart offers advanced e-commerce features like checkout customization and upsell tools, making it ideal for businesses looking to maximize sales and enhance customer experience.

  • Advanced checkout customization options.
  • Robust upsell features.
  • Comprehensive subscription management tools.
  • Slightly complex for beginners.
  • Higher cost for advanced features.

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$59 per month
Good Value For Price
4.0

0

author image
Big Cartel

Big Cartel provides a user-friendly platform with affordable pricing, perfect for small businesses and independent creators seeking a simple and effective online store solution.

  • User-friendly interface.
  • Affordable pricing.
  • Ideal for small businesses.
  • Limited upsell capabilities.
  • Basic subscription management.

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$12 per month

What is SamCart?

SamCart is a comprehensive e-commerce platform designed to simplify the process of selling products online. It offers a range of features including customizable checkout pages, one-click upsells, and subscription management. This tool is particularly beneficial for entrepreneurs and small businesses looking to maximize their sales potential without the need for extensive technical knowledge. With SamCart, you can easily create a seamless shopping experience for your customers, helping you to increase conversion rates and grow your business efficiently.

What is Big Cartel?

Big Cartel is a user-friendly e-commerce platform tailored for artists and small business owners who want to sell their products online. It provides a straightforward interface to set up an online store without the need for technical expertise. Big Cartel is ideal for those who want a simple, no-frills solution to showcase and sell their creative work. With its focus on simplicity and ease of use, Big Cartel helps users manage their online sales effortlessly, making it a popular choice for independent creators.

Pros and Cons of SamCart vs Big Cartel

author image

Pros & Cons of SamCart

Advanced checkout customization
  • SamCart offers advanced checkout customization options, allowing businesses to create a seamless and branded checkout experience. This feature is particularly beneficial for enhancing the customer journey and increasing conversion rates.
Robust upsell features
  • SamCart excels in upsell features, providing one-click upsells that can significantly boost sales. This feature is a game-changer for businesses looking to increase their average order value and maximize revenue.
Comprehensive subscription management
  • SamCart offers comprehensive subscription management tools, making it easy to handle recurring payments and subscriptions. This feature is ideal for businesses with subscription-based models, ensuring smooth operations.
Slightly complex for beginners
  • SamCart's extensive features may be slightly complex for beginners, requiring a learning curve to fully utilize its capabilities. This could be a drawback for those seeking a straightforward solution.
Higher cost for advanced features
  • SamCart's advanced features come at a higher cost, which may not be suitable for businesses on a tight budget. This could be a consideration for those looking for a more affordable option.
author image

Pros & Cons of Big Cartel

User-friendly interface
  • Big Cartel offers a user-friendly interface, making it easy for beginners to set up and manage their online store. This feature is ideal for those seeking a straightforward and hassle-free solution.
Affordable pricing
  • Big Cartel provides affordable pricing plans, making it accessible for small businesses and independent creators. This feature is particularly beneficial for those on a tight budget.
Ideal for small businesses
  • Big Cartel is ideal for small businesses and independent creators, offering a simple and effective platform to showcase and sell their products. This feature is perfect for those seeking a no-frills solution.
Limited upsell capabilities
  • Big Cartel's upsell capabilities are limited, which may not be suitable for businesses looking to maximize their revenue through upselling. This could be a drawback for those focused on increasing sales.
Basic subscription management
  • Big Cartel offers basic subscription management, which may not be sufficient for businesses with subscription-based models. This could be a consideration for those seeking more comprehensive tools.

SamCart vs Big Cartel: At A Glance

Decision FactorSamCartBig Cartel
Value to Price
Excellent4.5
Good4.0
Ease of Use
Good4.2
Excellent4.5
Functionality
Excellent4.4
Good3.8
Scalability
Excellent4.3
Good3.9
Integrations
Good4.1
Poor3.7
Customer Support
Good4.0
Good3.9
Security
Good4.2
Good4.1
Overall Rating
Excellent4.3
Good4.0

SamCart vs Big Cartel: A Detailed Breakdown of Key Features

FeaturesSamCartBig Cartel
Checkout Customization
Excellent4.5
Good3.8
Upsell Features
Excellent4.6
Poor3.5
Subscription Management
Excellent4.4
Poor3.6
Analytics and Reporting
Excellent4.3
Poor3.7
Mobile Optimization
Good4.2
Good4.0
SEO Tools
Good4.1
Good3.9

Checkout Customization

SamCart offers extensive checkout customization options, allowing you to create a seamless and branded checkout experience. This feature is particularly beneficial for businesses looking to enhance their customer journey. Big Cartel, while offering basic customization, may not provide the same level of flexibility. If you prioritize a tailored checkout process, SamCart is the better choice.

Upsell Features

SamCart excels in upsell features, providing one-click upsells that can significantly boost your sales. This feature is a game-changer for businesses looking to increase their average order value. Big Cartel's upsell capabilities are more limited, making SamCart the superior option for those focused on maximizing revenue.

Subscription Management

SamCart offers robust subscription management tools, making it easy to handle recurring payments and subscriptions. This feature is ideal for businesses with subscription-based models. Big Cartel's subscription management is less comprehensive, making SamCart the better choice for subscription businesses.

Analytics and Reporting

SamCart provides detailed analytics and reporting tools, giving you insights into your sales performance. This feature is crucial for data-driven decision-making. Big Cartel offers basic reporting, which may not be sufficient for businesses that rely heavily on analytics. If you need in-depth reporting, SamCart is the better option.

Mobile Optimization

Both SamCart and Big Cartel offer mobile optimization, ensuring your store looks great on any device. However, SamCart's mobile optimization is slightly more advanced, providing a smoother user experience. If mobile optimization is a priority, SamCart is the better choice.

SEO Tools

SamCart offers a range of SEO tools to help improve your store's visibility in search engines. This feature is essential for businesses looking to increase their online presence. Big Cartel's SEO tools are more basic, making SamCart the better option for those focused on SEO.

Pricing Comparison of SamCart and Big Cartel

To assist you in making an informed choice, we’ve outlined the pricing plans and essential features of SamCart and Big Cartel. This comparison will highlight the best option for creating your online store.

author image

SamCart Pricing Plans

Launch
For Small Businesses
$59

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Launch includes:
  • Enable Stripe Link to speed up time to checkout.
  • Accept payments from Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Buy Now, Pay Later.
  • Customize sales pages to fit your needs on any device.
  • Access templates designed to drive conversions and boost profits.
Grow
For Growing Businesses
$159

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Launch, plus:
  • Create products that your customers can add on to their order after they check out with just one click.
  • Create products that your customers can add on to their order before they check out.
  • Manage custom start and rebill dates.
  • Access automated workflows to mitigate cart abandonment.
Scale
For Large Enterprises
$319

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Grow, plus:
  • Integrate with the world’s best marketing and membership tools through custom API integration.
  • Leverage built-in dunning sequences to recover lost sales.
  • Build an affiliate army to sell your products, boost conversions, and grow brand awareness.
  • Advanced integrations with the most commonly used CRMs, such as Hubspot, InfusionSoft, and more.
author image

Big Cartel Pricing Plans

Free
For Small Businesses
$0

per month

Get Startedright_arrow
Free includes:
  • Manage your business and sell online with card and PayPal acceptance.
  • Mobile apps available for iOS and Android for easy management.
  • Import products from Etsy, Squarespace, and Shopify seamlessly.
  • Customize your store with free, SEO-optimized templates.
Platinum
For Growing Businesses
$12

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Free, plus:
  • Offer discounts and run promotions to boost sales.
  • Unlimited label printing with up to 90% off shipping.
  • Advanced template customization for a unique store look.
  • Track performance with Google Analytics integration.
Diamond
For Scaling Businesses
$24

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Platinum, plus:
  • Prioritized support and abandoned cart recovery for better service.
  • Ads with audience targeting for Google, Facebook, and more.
  • Advanced Google Analytics reporting for detailed insights.
  • Manage inventory with bulk editing and tracking features.

Our Rating Methodology

We thoroughly evaluate each e-commerce platform, focusing on key aspects like functionality, ease of use, and scalability. By analyzing user feedback and testing features, we ensure our recommendations align with your needs. Each factor is weighted to provide a reliable final rating, helping you make informed decisions.

Decision FactorScoring Weight
Value to Price
20%
20%
Ease of Use
20%
15%
Functionality
20%
25%
Scalability
20%
15%
Integrations
20%
10%
Customer Support
20%
10%
Security
20%
5%

SamCart or Big Cartel: Which One Matches Your Business Needs?

Choose SamCart If You Need ...

  • Advanced e-commerce features

    If you are a business looking for a platform with advanced e-commerce features like checkout customization and upsell tools, SamCart is the ideal choice. Its comprehensive tools can help you maximize sales and enhance customer experience.

  • Subscription-based business

    If you run a subscription-based business and need robust subscription management tools, SamCart is the better option. Its comprehensive features make it easy to handle recurring payments and subscriptions efficiently.

Choose Big Cartel If You Need ...

  • Simple and affordable solution

    If you are a small business or independent creator looking for a simple and affordable solution to set up an online store, Big Cartel is the perfect choice. Its user-friendly interface and affordable pricing make it accessible for those on a tight budget.

  • Beginner-friendly platform

    If you are a beginner seeking a straightforward and hassle-free platform to manage your online store, Big Cartel is the ideal choice. Its user-friendly interface makes it easy to set up and manage your store without technical expertise.

Frequently Asked Questions

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Martin Lunendonk is a senior tech writer specializing in website builders, web hosting, and ecommerce platforms. With a background in finance, accounting, and philosophy, he has founded multiple tech startups and worked in medium to large tech companies and investment banking, bringing deep expertise and reliable insights to his software reviews.