logo

Recurly vs Sellfy (2024 Comparison)

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Last Update

Nov 18, 2024

We earn a commission from partner links on Keevee. Commissions do not affect our editor's opinions or evaluations.

Excellent Value For Price
4.3

0

author image
Recurly

Recurly offers advanced subscription management and comprehensive analytics, making it ideal for businesses with complex billing needs. Its wide range of integrations enhances its functionality.

  • Advanced subscription management features
  • Comprehensive analytics and reporting
  • Wide range of integrations
  • Requires more setup time
  • Higher cost for small businesses

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$249 per month
Good Value For Price
4.1

0

author image
Sellfy

Sellfy provides a user-friendly interface and strong e-commerce tools, perfect for small businesses and creators. Its affordability makes it an attractive option for those starting out.

  • User-friendly interface
  • Affordable for small businesses
  • Strong e-commerce tools
  • Limited subscription features
  • Fewer integrations available

Free plan?

Yes

Starting price

$22 per month

What is Recurly?

Recurly is a subscription management platform that simplifies billing processes for businesses. It automates recurring billing, manages subscriptions, and provides insightful analytics. This tool is particularly beneficial for companies with a subscription-based model, as it helps streamline operations and improve customer retention. With Recurly, you can easily handle complex billing scenarios, reduce churn, and gain valuable insights into your revenue streams.

What is Sellfy?

Sellfy is an e-commerce platform designed for creators and small businesses to sell digital products, physical goods, and subscriptions. It offers a user-friendly interface, making it easy to set up an online store without technical expertise. Sellfy provides tools for marketing, analytics, and payment processing, helping users manage their sales efficiently. It's an ideal solution for those looking to monetize their creative work or expand their business online.

Pros and Cons of Recurly vs Sellfy

author image

Pros & Cons of Recurly

Advanced subscription management
  • Recurly offers a comprehensive suite of subscription management features, including automated billing and dunning management, which are essential for businesses with complex subscription models.
Comprehensive analytics
  • With Recurly, you gain access to detailed analytics and reporting tools that provide valuable insights into customer behavior and revenue trends, helping you make informed business decisions.
Wide range of integrations
  • Recurly integrates with numerous popular business tools, enhancing its functionality and allowing seamless data flow across platforms, which is crucial for businesses with diverse software needs.
Requires more setup time
  • Due to its advanced features, Recurly requires a more involved setup process, which may be challenging for businesses without dedicated IT resources or technical expertise.
Higher cost for small businesses
  • Recurly's pricing may be prohibitive for small businesses or startups, as its advanced features come at a higher cost compared to simpler e-commerce solutions.
author image

Pros & Cons of Sellfy

User-friendly interface
  • Sellfy's intuitive interface makes it easy for users to set up and manage their online store without technical expertise, making it an ideal choice for small businesses and creators.
Affordable for small businesses
  • Sellfy offers competitive pricing, making it an attractive option for small businesses and creators looking to establish an online presence without breaking the bank.
Strong e-commerce tools
  • Sellfy provides a robust set of e-commerce tools, including product management and digital product delivery, which are essential for businesses looking to sell online effectively.
Limited subscription features
  • Sellfy's subscription features are basic and may not meet the needs of businesses with complex subscription models, making it less suitable for those heavily reliant on subscriptions.
Fewer integrations available
  • Sellfy offers fewer integrations compared to other platforms, which may limit its functionality for businesses that rely on a wide range of software tools.

Recurly vs Sellfy: At A Glance

Decision FactorRecurlySellfy
Value to Price
Excellent4.5
Good4.2
Ease of Use
Good4.2
Excellent4.4
Functionality
Excellent4.6
Excellent4.3
Scalability
Excellent4.4
Good4.1
Integrations
Excellent4.3
Good4.0
Customer Support
Good4.2
Good4.1
Security
Excellent4.5
Good4.2
Overall Rating
Excellent4.3
Good4.1

Recurly vs Sellfy: A Detailed Breakdown of Key Features

FeaturesRecurlySellfy
Subscription Management
Excellent4.7
Good4.0
E-commerce Tools
Good4.2
Excellent4.5
Analytics and Reporting
Excellent4.6
Good4.1
Payment Processing
Excellent4.5
Excellent4.3
Customization Options
Excellent4.3
Good4.2
Marketing Tools
Good4.1
Excellent4.4

Subscription Management

Recurly excels in subscription management with features like automated billing, dunning management, and revenue recognition. These tools are invaluable for businesses with complex subscription models. Sellfy, while offering basic subscription options, lacks the depth and automation of Recurly. If your business relies heavily on subscriptions, Recurly is the superior choice.

E-commerce Tools

Sellfy provides a comprehensive suite of e-commerce tools, including product management, discount codes, and digital product delivery. Recurly offers e-commerce capabilities but is more focused on subscription services. If your primary need is a robust e-commerce platform, Sellfy is the better option.

Analytics and Reporting

Recurly offers advanced analytics and reporting features, providing insights into customer behavior and revenue trends. Sellfy provides basic analytics, sufficient for small businesses but lacking the depth of Recurly. For businesses that require detailed reporting, Recurly is the preferred choice.

Payment Processing

Both Recurly and Sellfy offer reliable payment processing options, supporting multiple payment gateways. Recurly's strength lies in its ability to handle complex billing scenarios, while Sellfy provides straightforward payment solutions. If you need advanced payment processing, Recurly is the better choice.

Customization Options

Recurly offers extensive customization options, allowing businesses to tailor their subscription processes. Sellfy provides customization for storefronts and product pages, suitable for small businesses. If you need deep customization capabilities, Recurly is the superior option.

Marketing Tools

Sellfy offers a range of marketing tools, including email marketing and upselling features, to help boost sales. Recurly provides basic marketing capabilities, focusing more on subscription management. If marketing is a priority, Sellfy is the better choice.

Pricing Comparison of Recurly and Sellfy

We’ve compiled the pricing tables and highlighted the key features of both Recurly and Sellfy to aid in your decision-making process. Let’s explore what each platform has to offer.

author image

Recurly Pricing Plans

Starter
For startups and SMBs
$249

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Starter includes:
  • Flexible pricing models to suit diverse needs.
  • Trials and promotions to attract new customers.
  • Robust subscription management for seamless operations.
  • Supports 30+ languages and 140+ currencies.
Professional
For midsize companies
Contact sales
Request Pricingright_arrow
Includes Starter, plus:
  • Intelligent retries to minimize payment failures.
  • Backup payment method for uninterrupted service.
  • Gift cards to enhance customer engagement.
  • ACH payment method for flexible transactions.
Elite
For large enterprises
Contact sales
Request Pricingright_arrow
Includes Professional, plus:
  • Custom report builder for tailored insights.
  • Advanced email deliverability for effective communication.
  • Oracle NetSuite integration for seamless operations.
  • Dedicated Customer Success Manager for personalized support.
author image

Sellfy Pricing Plans

Starter
For Small Businesses
$22

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Starter includes:
  • Offer unlimited digital and subscription products.
  • Connect your own domain for branding.
  • Utilize built-in email marketing tools.
  • No transaction fees or hidden costs involved.
Business
For Growing Businesses
$59

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Starter, plus:
  • Enhance sales with product upselling features.
  • Recover lost sales with cart abandonment tools.
  • Leverage affiliate marketing to boost reach.
  • Remove Sellfy branding for a professional look.
Premium
For Large Enterprises
$119

per month

Try For Freeright_arrow
Includes Business, plus:
  • Seamlessly migrate products with ease.
  • Access priority support for quick resolutions.
  • Benefit from advanced store design migration.
  • Ideal for high-volume sellers needing robust features.

Our Rating Methodology

We rigorously evaluate each e-commerce platform, focusing on key factors like functionality, ease of use, and scalability. By analyzing user reviews and testing features, we ensure our recommendations are reliable. Each factor is weighted to provide an accurate final rating, helping you make informed decisions.

Decision FactorScoring Weight
Value to Price
20%
20%
Ease of Use
20%
15%
Functionality
20%
25%
Scalability
20%
15%
Integrations
20%
10%
Customer Support
20%
10%
Security
20%
5%

Recurly or Sellfy: Which One Matches Your Business Needs?

Choose Recurly If You Need ...

  • Advanced subscription management

    If you are a business with complex subscription models, Recurly's advanced subscription management features, including automated billing and dunning management, make it the ideal choice for streamlining your operations.

  • Comprehensive analytics

    If you need detailed insights into customer behavior and revenue trends, Recurly's comprehensive analytics and reporting tools provide valuable data to help you make informed business decisions.

Choose Sellfy If You Need ...

  • User-friendly e-commerce platform

    If you are a small business or creator looking for an easy-to-use e-commerce platform, Sellfy's intuitive interface and strong e-commerce tools make it the perfect choice for setting up your online store.

  • Affordable for small businesses

    If you are a small business or creator on a budget, Sellfy's competitive pricing and robust e-commerce tools provide an affordable solution for establishing an online presence without breaking the bank.

Frequently Asked Questions

author image
Author

Martin Lunendonk

Martin Lunendonk is a senior tech writer specializing in website builders, web hosting, and ecommerce platforms. With a background in finance, accounting, and philosophy, he has founded multiple tech startups and worked in medium to large tech companies and investment banking, bringing deep expertise and reliable insights to his software reviews.