Big Cartel vs Sellfy (2024 Comparison)
Big Cartel is a user-friendly platform perfect for small businesses and artists. With customizable themes and affordable pricing, it offers a simple solution for those looking to start selling online quickly.
- Simple setup process
- Affordable for small businesses
- Customizable themes available
- Limited marketing tools
- Basic digital product support
Free plan?
YesStarting price
$12 per month
Sellfy provides a powerful e-commerce solution with advanced marketing tools and seamless digital product sales. Ideal for creators looking to expand their online presence and boost sales effectively.
- Advanced marketing tools
- Seamless digital product sales
- Extensive social media integration
- Higher cost for advanced features
- Limited free plan options
Free plan?
YesStarting price
$22 per monthWhat is Big Cartel?
Big Cartel is a platform designed for artists and creators to sell their work online. It offers a simple and intuitive interface, making it easy for users to set up their online store without any technical expertise. With customizable themes and straightforward inventory management, Big Cartel helps small businesses and independent creators showcase their products beautifully. It’s perfect for those who want a no-fuss solution to start selling online quickly.
What is Sellfy?
Sellfy is an e-commerce platform that caters to digital product sellers, offering a seamless way to sell digital goods, subscriptions, and physical products. It provides a user-friendly interface with built-in marketing tools, allowing creators to reach their audience effectively. Sellfy's integration with social media and email marketing makes it a powerful tool for those looking to expand their online presence and boost sales. It's ideal for creators who want to monetize their digital content effortlessly.
Pros and Cons of Big Cartel vs Sellfy
Pros & Cons of Big Cartel
- Big Cartel offers a straightforward setup process, making it easy for users to get their online store up and running quickly. This simplicity is ideal for those who want to start selling without any technical hurdles.
- Big Cartel provides cost-effective plans that cater to small businesses and independent creators. This affordability makes it accessible for those with limited budgets, allowing them to establish an online presence without breaking the bank.
- With a variety of customizable themes, Big Cartel allows users to create a unique storefront that reflects their brand's identity. This flexibility is beneficial for those who want to stand out in the crowded online marketplace.
- Big Cartel's marketing tools are basic, lacking the advanced features found in other platforms. This limitation can hinder businesses looking to expand their reach and engage with a broader audience effectively.
- While Big Cartel supports digital product sales, its features are limited compared to other platforms. This basic support may not meet the needs of businesses focused on selling digital goods.
Pros & Cons of Sellfy
- Sellfy offers a comprehensive suite of marketing tools, including email campaigns and discount codes, allowing businesses to effectively reach and engage their target audience. This advanced functionality is ideal for those looking to boost sales.
- Sellfy excels in digital product sales, providing seamless integration and delivery options. This capability is perfect for creators who want to monetize their digital content effortlessly and efficiently.
- With extensive social media integration, Sellfy enables businesses to reach a wider audience and increase their online presence. This feature is beneficial for those looking to leverage social media for growth.
- Sellfy's advanced features come at a higher cost, which may not be suitable for businesses with limited budgets. This pricing can be a barrier for those looking for affordable solutions.
- Sellfy offers limited options for free plans, which may not provide enough features for businesses to fully explore the platform's capabilities. This limitation can be a drawback for those wanting to test the platform before committing.
Big Cartel vs Sellfy: At A Glance
Value to Price
Big Cartel offers a cost-effective solution for small businesses and artists, providing essential features at a reasonable price. However, Sellfy provides more advanced features and marketing tools, making it a better value for those looking to scale their business. If you need more comprehensive tools for growth, Sellfy is the better choice.
Ease of Use
Both Big Cartel and Sellfy are user-friendly, but Sellfy's interface is slightly more intuitive, especially for beginners. It offers a smoother onboarding process and more straightforward navigation. If you prioritize ease of use, Sellfy is the more accessible option.
Functionality
Sellfy excels in functionality with its robust set of features, including digital product sales and marketing tools. Big Cartel, while functional, is more basic and suited for smaller operations. For those needing advanced functionality, Sellfy is the superior choice.
Scalability
Sellfy offers better scalability options, allowing businesses to grow without limitations. Big Cartel is ideal for smaller businesses but may not support larger operations as effectively. If scalability is a priority, Sellfy is the more suitable platform.
Integrations
Both platforms offer integrations, but Sellfy provides a wider range of options, including social media and email marketing tools. Big Cartel's integrations are more limited. For those needing extensive integration capabilities, Sellfy is the better option.
Customer Support
Sellfy offers more comprehensive customer support, including live chat and email support. Big Cartel provides support but is more limited in scope. If customer support is crucial, Sellfy offers a more reliable service.
Security
Both platforms prioritize security, but Sellfy offers more advanced security features, ensuring a safer environment for transactions. Big Cartel provides basic security measures. For enhanced security, Sellfy is the preferred choice.
Overall Rating
Overall, Sellfy scores higher due to its advanced features, ease of use, and scalability. Big Cartel is a solid choice for smaller businesses but lacks some of the advanced capabilities of Sellfy. For a more comprehensive solution, Sellfy is the better option.
Big Cartel vs Sellfy: A Detailed Breakdown of Key Features
Customizable Themes
Big Cartel offers a range of customizable themes that allow you to create a unique storefront. However, Sellfy provides more advanced customization options, enabling you to tailor your store to your brand's specific needs. If you value extensive customization, Sellfy is the better choice.
Digital Product Sales
Sellfy excels in digital product sales, offering seamless integration and delivery options. Big Cartel supports digital sales but lacks some of the advanced features found in Sellfy. For those focused on digital products, Sellfy is the superior platform.
Marketing Tools
Sellfy provides a comprehensive suite of marketing tools, including email campaigns and discount codes. Big Cartel offers basic marketing features but doesn't match Sellfy's capabilities. If marketing is a priority, Sellfy offers more robust tools.
Inventory Management
Both platforms offer inventory management, but Sellfy's system is more intuitive and feature-rich. Big Cartel provides basic inventory tracking, suitable for smaller operations. For advanced inventory needs, Sellfy is the better option.
Social Media Integration
Sellfy offers extensive social media integration, allowing you to reach a broader audience. Big Cartel provides basic social media links but lacks the depth of Sellfy's integration. For those leveraging social media, Sellfy is the preferred choice.
Email Marketing
Sellfy's email marketing tools are more advanced, offering automated campaigns and analytics. Big Cartel provides basic email marketing features. If email marketing is crucial, Sellfy offers a more comprehensive solution.
Pricing Comparison of Big Cartel and Sellfy
We’ve compiled the pricing tables and highlighted the key features of both Big Cartel and Sellfy to aid in your decision-making process. Let’s explore what each platform has to offer.
Big Cartel Pricing Plans
- Manage your business and sell online with card and PayPal acceptance.
- Mobile apps available for iOS and Android for easy management.
- Import products from Etsy, Squarespace, and Shopify seamlessly.
- Customize your store with free, SEO-optimized templates.
- Offer discounts and run promotions to boost sales.
- Unlimited label printing with up to 90% off shipping.
- Advanced template customization for a unique store look.
- Track performance with Google Analytics integration.
- Prioritized support and abandoned cart recovery for better service.
- Ads with audience targeting for Google, Facebook, and more.
- Advanced Google Analytics reporting for detailed insights.
- Manage inventory with bulk editing and tracking features.
Sellfy Pricing Plans
- Offer unlimited digital and subscription products.
- Connect your own domain for branding.
- Utilize built-in email marketing tools.
- No transaction fees or hidden costs involved.
- Enhance sales with product upselling features.
- Recover lost sales with cart abandonment tools.
- Leverage affiliate marketing to boost reach.
- Remove Sellfy branding for a professional look.
- Seamlessly migrate products with ease.
- Access priority support for quick resolutions.
- Benefit from advanced store design migration.
- Ideal for high-volume sellers needing robust features.
Our Rating Methodology
We thoroughly evaluate each e-commerce platform, focusing on key aspects like functionality, ease of use, and scalability. By analyzing user feedback and testing features, we ensure our recommendations align with your needs. Each factor is weighted to provide a reliable final rating, helping you make informed decisions.
Big Cartel or Sellfy: Which One Matches Your Business Needs?
Choose Big Cartel If You Need ...
- Simple and Affordable Solution
If you are a small business owner or artist looking for a simple and affordable solution to start selling online, Big Cartel is the perfect choice. Its user-friendly interface and customizable themes make it easy to set up your store quickly.
- Customizable Storefront
If you want to create a unique storefront that reflects your brand's identity, Big Cartel offers a range of customizable themes. This flexibility allows you to stand out in the crowded online marketplace.
Choose Sellfy If You Need ...
- Advanced Marketing Tools
If you need advanced marketing tools to reach and engage your target audience effectively, Sellfy is the ideal platform. Its comprehensive suite of marketing features allows you to boost sales and grow your business.
- Seamless Digital Product Sales
If you are focused on selling digital products, Sellfy provides seamless integration and delivery options. This capability makes it easy to monetize your digital content and expand your online presence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform is better for digital product sales?
Which platform offers more customization options?
Which platform is more affordable for small businesses?
Which platform offers better marketing tools?
Which platform is easier to use for beginners?
Which platform offers better customer support?
Martin Lunendonk
Martin Lunendonk is a senior tech writer specializing in website builders, web hosting, and ecommerce platforms. With a background in finance, accounting, and philosophy, he has founded multiple tech startups and worked in medium to large tech companies and investment banking, bringing deep expertise and reliable insights to his software reviews.
